CertainPath vs. Nexstar: Which Contractor Coaching Program Actually Grows Your Business?

Last Updated: November 18, 2026

CertainPath HVAC Coaching Session

As a contractor, looking for a coaching program can be confusing. There are a number of options, including CertainPath and Nexstar, but not all of them will fit your needs or help you reach your goals the way you want to.

Nexstar is a respected, member-owned network with a strong following, and understanding how the comparison between Nexstar vs. CertainPath can help you choose a path forward. Here’s what to know about their philosophies, systems, software, and community, along with how to get started with a CertainPath coach, so you can choose the right opportunity and style of coaching for your future plans.

CertainPath and Nexstar at a Glance

Nexstar was founded in 1992 and offers primarily HVAC and plumbing coaching, with some electrical coaching. Headquartered in Bloomington, Minnesota, the company uses a member-owned network model.

In contrast, CertainPath was founded in 1999 and is headquartered in Addison, Texas. We offer coaching for HVAC, plumbing, electrical, and roofing contractors, with a coaching and technology membership model distinct from what Nexstar provides.

If you’re looking for a Nexstar network alternative to advance your contracting business, our coaching services at CertainPath can help you move your company forward.

Coaching Philosophy and Approach

At CertainPath, we offer a dedicated, one-on-one training and coaching model that’s focused on your business. Our coaches listen to what you actually need and work to understand where you are in your journey. With that information, we can guide you through the concerns you have, help you see how to grow your contracting business, and give you ongoing guidance you can rely on.

We’ll build our coaching around your specific home service business, whether that’s plumbing, roofing, HVAC, or electrical, and take the size of your company and how long it’s been established into account. There’s a lot more to coaching than just the kind of business you operate, so the goal is to ensure the coaching you receive is tailored to your specific needs and situation.

Nexstar offers a peer-group and shared-benchmarking approach to coaching that can also be valuable for some businesses, depending on exactly what they’re looking for. With a tight-knit peer community, it’s possible to make important connections and get valuable business development resources from joining the company’s coaching program.

However, success stories often speak for themselves, and at CertainPath, we have plenty of happy contractors who’ve used our coaching services to take their businesses to the next level.

Dan Worstell, for example, has shared how we helped increase his success with Pyramid Roofing in Norfolk, VA. Through the value of strong coaching and implementing what he learned, he’s found that his employees stay much longer, and he has far less turnover in his company. Everyone works as a team and builds a bond over time, leading to higher levels of success and a group of technicians and professionals who all have the same goals.

Business Systems and Training Depth

At CertainPath, we use proprietary systems in financial management, sales training, and operations to provide contractors with the training they need to advance their business’ goals. Through working with us, you can enjoy multi-trade flexibility by expanding beyond HVAC into plumbing, roofing, and electrical.

Many contractors start in one of these areas and move into others as their companies grow, but doing that isn’t always an easy road. Having the right style of coaching and level of support can make all the difference, especially as owners try to streamline operations while adding new services and employees.

With all-in-one field service software and higher group purchasing power through our Partner Network, you’ll have an intersection of technology and supply chain access that’s hard to beat.

Nexstar offers a more rigid, structured plan for getting you to where you want to be. That can be an excellent option for a new contractor who’s just starting out and isn’t sure what path to take, but may not be as effective if you’re more established and looking for more of a partnership, not a boss.

You can expect a custom business plan from Nexstar, as well as individualized coaching, but not the highly personalized goal setting from the very first day that’s offered through CertainPath. Whether you choose CertainPath vs. Nexstar network options comes down to the depth of training you want, need, and expect, as well as other factors that differ between the coaching programs.

Technology and Software Support

One of the biggest differentiators in the Nexstar vs. CertainPath debate is in technology and software support. Nexstar is focused on coaching and network first, while CertainPath offers a more software-forward experience.

When you work with Nexstar you can expect a feel that’s similar to an executive business program. It’s polished and professional, and offers metrics-driven coaching that spans every business aspect. The coaching program emphasizes operations and systems to drive the growth of your business and increase future profit margins, with attention to performance metrics that help owners understand what’s working and what needs improvement. It’s generally best for contractors seeking structure, data, and some tough love along the way.

At CertainPath, our field service software, which includes scheduling, dispatch, reporting, and invoicing, integrates right into our coaching program and doesn’t require a separate vendor. In contrast, contractors who choose Nexstar generally need to source their own field software separately and integrate it into the program.

That can be easy for some, and frustrating for others, depending on how established they are and whether they already have a software vendor. If you’re just starting out, looking to expand your business into other areas, or looking at more rapid growth, having to take time to seek out, test out, and integrate software may not be something you want to entertain. With us at CertainPath, you won’t have to.

For example, many contractors are using CertainPath and ServiceTitan to grow businesses and keep everything in one place. Having the right software is a significant part of ongoing goal development, customer satisfaction, dispatching, scheduling, and tracking important numbers such as revenue, conversion rates, and average ticket. When contractors combine quality coaching and high-tech software, it’s easier and more convenient for everyone involved.

Community and Peer Network

Nexstar heavily markets its relationship and networking side, with a community of 800+ like-minded contractors to work with, learn from, and gain experience through. At CertainPath, we have a community of 1,500+ contractors for support, including HVAC professionals, plumbers, roofers, and electrical contractors, so you can get your questions answered, see how others are handling their business concerns, and explore new ways to grow and develop your company over time.

While Nexstar offers a peer-group model with member-to-member benchmarking and shared best practices, CertainPath offers a dedicated coaching relationship, along with in-person events like Expo and the Dallas training program. We’ve been helping contractors like you transform their businesses for decades, and our reviews showcase the value that members of our coaching programs receive.

According to Mason, “James Caudle did a great job at giving us his expertise. Very informative class and appreciate all of the training/insight! Hoping to take further classes in the future!”

Additionally, Chase says, “Great class, learned from James Caudle. Not only was this class informative, but also helped walk us through each step we should take for a successful residential HVAC call. I have taken a lot away from this training, thank you CertainPath.”

When you’re learning and growing as a business, community matters, and both Nexstar and CertainPath offer peer opportunities. The styles may be different, but the overall goal of ensuring you have others to mentor you and help you grow is the same.

Membership Cost and Investment

If you want to become a member of CertainPath or get involved with Nexstar, one of your biggest questions is probably, “How much will it cost?” Especially if you have a smaller contracting business or you’re just starting out, that’s a very fair question to have.

It’s essential to look at the cost of either program as an investment in your business and its future. First-year fees for Nexstar are around $20,000, with subsequent years typically costing between $10,000 and $15,000. Many contractors feel this expense is worth it because of the potential return on investment they may receive.

Because Nexstar is committed to 10%+ revenue growth and 15%+ net profit targets, many contractors decide to take the chance and spend the money on coaching.

At CertainPath, we have a similar investment structure, with the first year generally being the highest level of investment and subsequent years requiring lower investment levels. Only you can decide what’s right for your needs, but joining a coaching program is a serious commitment that may help your home services business see the kind of growth that can take you and your company to a new level.

Remember, it’s about return on investment, not sticker price, and contractors that share their stories generally talk about the dramatic growth they’ve experienced from working with a coaching program. No coaching program is guaranteed, but finding the right one for your business may make a significant difference in your future profit margins and bottom line.

Which Program Fits Your Business

Deciding which program is right for your needs is an essential way to help your business grow. There’s no one correct answer for everyone, even if two contractors have the same niche, company size, and other details. They’re still very different businesses.

If you’re an owner who’s looking for hands-on or individualized coaching options with integrated software for multi-trade businesses, CertainPath is generally the better choice. On the other hand, if you’re an owner who’s not focused on individual coaching, but who may prioritize a large peer benchmarking network, Nexstar could be a better option.

Many contractors talk to more than one coaching program representative before making a decision, and you may want to do that as well. A lot of the time, that clarifies things faster than just looking at comparison data, and can help you make a decision with confidence. You can book a call with us at CertainPath today to get your questions answered.

See What Individualized Coaching Can Do for Your Business

While there’s plenty to think about in the Nexstar vs. CertainPath debate, the biggest differentiator is that CertainPath has individualized coaching plus integrated software, which is something you just won’t find with Nexstar.

If you’re looking for faster growth and higher profit margins, and you want to see the blending of coaching and software in action, schedule a demo today. We’ll walk you through our offerings, answer your questions, and show you how integrated software and individualized coaching blend into a program that can move your business forward for the long term.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is CertainPath better than Nexstar for HVAC contractors?

Neither CertainPath nor Nexstar is necessarily better for HVAC contractors, and it depends mostly on what you’re specifically looking for. If you want to expand into other home service areas like plumbing, electrical, or roofing, or if you’re looking for individual coaching coupled with integrated software, CertainPath has the advantage.

 

What is the main difference between CertainPath and Nexstar Coaching?

The biggest difference between CertainPath and Nexstar coaching is that CertainPath coaching reviews talk about the individual nature of the experience and the building of a specific plan right from the beginning. Nexstar is more peer-focused and structured, with less opportunity for adjustment.

Does CertainPath offer software as part of its coaching membership?

Yes, CertainPath offers integrated software as part of its coaching program. That’s one of its advantages over Nexstar for contractors who don’t already have specific software they want to integrate with a coaching program and keep using.

How much does CertainPath coaching cost compared to Nexstar membership?

CertainPath doesn’t offer specific figures, but its coaching costs are likely very similar to Nexstar membership. The two programs have a number of similarities, but both are distinctive in how they provide their services and what’s included with membership.

Can a contractor switch from Nexstar to CertainPath?

Yes, contractors who are already with Nexstar don’t have to stay there. They can leave that organization and join CertainPath, although a strategy call is required before joining to ensure their business is a fit for the coaching program.

Does CertainPath support electrical, plumbing, and roofing businesses or only HVAC?

CertainPath supports HVAC, electrical, plumbing, and roofing businesses looking for coaching and peer network support. If you’re in one of these trades, especially if you’re looking to expand into others, it may be right for your needs.

Last Updated: November 18, 2026

Explore More

Interested in a One-on-One Consultation?